Thoughts on Individuality and Death
Posted By James On 31st January 2008 @ 14:04 In Me | 4 Comments
The last few months have been full of thoughts of my dad, who passed away last fall. It's interesting how his death has affected me and my outlook on life. While I cannot honestly call myself a philosopher, I have attempted over the last 5 years or so to delve into my own beliefs and try to formulate my own philosophy of the world. As many who know me well can attest, this has involved a lot of change in my religious orientation and my attitude toward the idea of God.
I think the main thing that religion can impart is a strong sense of hope. Especially in my Mormon upbringing, death marked a sad but ultimately temporary separation. For those that believe, God will make everything work out for the best, if we only have the patience to wait. I know this gives a lot of comfort to many people and is probably one of the strongest arguments for the religious life.
With my dad's passing I found myself without this traditional religious comfort. Many people would find this very depressing (and have told me so); I suppose this is because many people don't have enough experience with atheism or atheists to know how they might deal with death's finality. For my own part, I find myself more and more understanding this event through Buddhist teachings about individuality. Perhaps an analogy will help explain.
If I see a cloud, I say, "there is a cloud". It is distinct from other clouds by its shape, contours, color and position in the sky. However, each moment that passes the cloud changes. At first the changes are very small, and I can still identify the overall shape and color of the cloud. After an hour, the cloud is gone, and in its place are more clouds. Am I right to bemoan the loss of the cloud? The matter from which the cloud consisted has not been destroyed. Rather, it was my characterization of the cloud as an individual thing that caused my suffering at its passing. The cloud never existed; what I saw was a mischaracterization, the temporary manifestation of something that is really a part of everything.
Christians might see in this analogy a reference to the separation of body and soul that happens at death. Being a materialist (in the sense of believing that the natural world is the only world), I might say that my sadness at my father's death is caused not by his passing, but by my misunderstanding of the actual nature of human life. Was the soul of my father truly a thing distinct from nature? Of what did my father consist?
This question helps me realize that people are not so much substance as they are cause and effect. My dad had experiences that made him distinct from other people, but he was also constantly changing as his experiences changed. The dad I remember from my early childhood is not the same man I remember in his last hours of pain and sickness. Similarly, he did not consist solely of his body or soul, but of his effect on others, and the memories that I still carry from his life. His existence was not concentrated in his physical body, but was diffused throughout the world, both before and after his death.
I'm certainly no expert on Buddhism or any other religion for that matter, and the idea that the "self" doesn't actually exist in individuals is very difficult to think about (namely because it is impossible to think about anything without characterizing it as something distinct from other things). Perhaps my beliefs are a bit mystical, but they have helped me find understanding regarding my dad's passing and my own reaction to it.
4 Comments To "Thoughts on Individuality and Death"
#1 Comment By Ryan Scott On 31st January 2008 @ 17:48
A spirit is a unique individual, eternal in nature. The body is likewise unique but mortal. When a person dies, their spirit goes to a heaven where they live, work, and associate with those who have gone before them. One day, the body will again take form, this time perfected, and spirit and body will reunite, never to die physically again. And, just as the body and spirit are reunited and perfected, so will our memories and experiences be reunited and perfected. The only true hope--the only true comfort--comes from faith (belief, action, power) in true principles.
#2 Comment By Jon Scott On 27th February 2008 @ 10:46
As someone once said..."You can't win, .... If you strike me down, I shall become more powerful than you could possibly imagine."
--Obi-Wan Kenobi--
Although this is a mere statement in a movie I believe my father has become more powerful than we can possibly imagine. and despite the philosophies of man, which can be from confusing up to totally not making sense to any rational person, i believe i will see my father again in as i once was able to. to hug him. to honor him. anything less than that would be short of true joy. I know my Father lives, i know he loves me.
I am a child of God.
#3 Comment By Captain On 1st March 2008 @ 07:18
Hi there.
Lately, I have been doing a lot of translation for a Buddhist religion (they call themselves an "institute"). I have been intrigued on their views of life, the purpose thereof, and what they think of the afterlife. There are some great works by Kukai, a great Buddhist master (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K%C5%ABkai) that you might find interesting.
One thought on the soul, or spirit, that I found particularly beautiful was that the soul, or intangible part of a person, is not found within, but is an emotional reaction to a connection with another person, place, or object. This mindset puts our "souls" outside of us and more in the ethereal plane than any real object. The analogy goes on to say that these connections are important and should be treasured but should not hold you back on your progression towards enlightenment.
Take it for whatever you think it is worth, but I think it's a nice sentiment.
Cheers,
Captain Adam
#4 Comment By Mom On 5th June 2008 @ 13:42
I truly believe in an actual God (our spiritual Father), and in His Son, Jesus Christ, who is our brother. Why do people have to make my religion so complicated, or life so complicated? When we try to do that, we make a jumble of common sense. I longingly look forward to that day when I will be reunited with my husband and other family members. To not believe that would be utter despair and ridiculousness.
When my mother passed away, she was given a blessing by two priesthood holders in the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints: one of comfort and peace. My mother was always afraid of dying, but in those last two days of her life, she was truly at peace and knew that our Heavenly Father loved her and was waiting to welcome her. Her visage was one of joy and peace. Can I deny the Holy Spirit? No. Will I pray for those who do not understand? Yes. I will never give up on those who are trying to quell that Spirit in their own lives. And neither will Heavenly Father.
I agree with Jon when he says that his father has become more powerful since his death. I feel that, too, and have had it manifested to me several times. He has the ability on the other side of the veil to work doubly hard to help instill the Spirit of God in his children, and influence their lives in a way he never could in this life. This is my testimony.
Link to article: http://www.scottcorner.org/2008/thoughts-on-individuality-and-death/